Why Diets Don’t Work

14th January 2016 | Tags: ,

It can be so frustrating when you have put in lots of time and energy, not to mention £5 every week to be weighed only to find that 6 weeks after you have finished your planned diet and gone back to normal life you now exceeded your original weight.

When we plan a diet and it could be any diet, the 5:2, weight watchers, or just calorie controlled, we generally take a stick to it at all costs approach. The results are we lose weight as you would expect – but this is usually because you are taking in less calories than before or if you are on a detox or very low calorie diet then a lot less calories than before.

One thing it might be useful to remember is that our bodies have evolved over thousands of years and they have had to survive feast and famine. To survive a time of famine or low calorie intake, our body will slow down, it will slow down all sorts of bodily functions, like the digestion of food, liver function, and basic metabolism. This results in the number of calories being burnt by your body slowing down… not exactly what you need for a long term weight loss plan.

The other thing it would be useful to remember is that our body and mind are programmed for survival not demise. When your body needs fuel you will feel hungry and we are definitely not programmed to like this feeling, its a signal that we have run out of fuel and need some more.

So when you eventually come off of your diet, or your mind and body win and you start eating again there are two main contributions to your rapid weight gain:

  1. Your basal metabolic rate is now slower then before and you will not burn as many calories at rest as you did before your diet.
  2. Your body doesn’t like being starved so it will readily store fats in case of future starvation.

Ideally the best way to approach weight loss is by taking the time to log a lifestyle diary – figure out what your daily habits are, when you are going to sit down for long periods of time, when do you exercise. Then make a plan to fit this, set some sensible ground rules, like:

  1. Eat a balanced diet.
  2. Stick to about 2000 calories if you are female and 2500 if you are male. 
  3. Organise your meals for the week.
  4. Write a shopping list and order online so that you are not tempted by other goodies in the supermarket.
  5. Eat slowly and chew your food properly.
  6. Take a packed lunch to work – know what you are eating.
  7. Exercise regularly at a level that you can manage – if you push too hard at the beginning you will hate it when the novelty has worn off.
  8. Drink plenty of fluid – water, cordial or fruit teas.
  9. Avoid fizzy sugary drinks.
  10. Limit alcohol to a sensible volume 14 units for ladies, 21 for men.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.